Protest as Confrontation or Useless Ritual

33 posts / 0 new
Last post
fatalriots2020's picture
Protest as Confrontation or Useless Ritual

Trump outside the Church of John the Revelator

https://youtu.be/hC_sqi9oocI

https://www.sltrib.com/resizer/saoMfnJb4S9JnOOzF5kyZZoVULQ=/0x600/smart/...(86)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/sltrib/D35KEELJHBEF3CS4WNB4SBWM2Q.jpg

John the Revelator?

For further clarification

Herbert Marcuse - The prophet of violence

https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/marcuse/works/1967/violence.htm

"My answer is based on the American situation, but you will see that you can easily infer from it what applies to your own. These demonstrations are not confrontations when they remain within the framework of legality. But when they do so, they subject themselves to the institutionalized violence that autonomously determines the framework of legality and can restrict it to a suffocating minimum; for example, by applying laws such as those forbidding trespass on private or government property, interfering with traffic, disturbance of the peace, etc. Accordingly what was legal can become illegal from one minute to the next if a completely peaceful demonstration disturbs the peace or voluntarily or involuntarily trespasses on private property, and so on. In this situation confrontations with state power, with institutionalized violence, seem inevitable – unless opposition becomes a harmless ritual, a pacifier of conscience, and a star witness for the rights and freedoms available under the status quo. This was the experience of the civil rights movement: that the others practice the violence, that the others are the violence, and that against this violence legality is problematic from the very beginning. This will also be the experience of the student opposition as soon as the system feels threatened by it. And then the opposition is placed before the fatal decision: opposition as ritual event or opposition as resistance, i.e. civil disobedience."

For further clarification

HTTPS://www.dennismarkuze.com

Attachments

Yes

Subscription Note: 

Choosing to subscribe to this topic will automatically register you for email notifications for comments and updates on this thread.

Email notifications will be sent out daily by default unless specified otherwise on your account which you can edit by going to your userpage here and clicking on the subscriptions tab.

fatalriots2020's picture
Here is the pic:

Here is the pic:

Attachments

Attach Image/Video?: 

Yes
dogalmighty's picture
@DM

@DM

Nostradamus was a charlatan.

Please take your meds.

In before the lock.

Nyarlathotep's picture
doG - In before the lock.

doG - In before the lock.

Yep, he is locked now.

dogalmighty's picture
@nyar

@nyar

3 IBTL's...not too shabby.

fatalriots2020's picture
@doG and you are a nobody :)

@doG

and you are a nobody :)

dogalmighty's picture
@DM

@DM

"@doG

and you are a nobody :)"

Wrong...I am doG, the charlatan hunter. :)

Nostradamus was paid by stupid people, for vague assertions that would fit any narrative with a little imagination.

PS. In before the lock.

boomer47's picture
@fatalriots

@fatalriots

@doG

and you are a nobody :)

And you are Dennis Markuze, one of the more notorious and pathetic internet trolls.

A pity really .On first glance I was looking forward to a discussion about demonstrations, social movements and revolutions as middle class phenomena.

'bye Dennis.

fatalriots2020's picture
well, with the twin towers,

well, with the twin towers, eclipse monsters, the current plague, spacecrafts destroyed on Mars, atheists blowing themselves up, we got a pretty good track record.

come see

https://www.dennismarkuze.com

dogalmighty's picture
@DM

@DM

Thanks for the validation.

In before the lock.

Ooooooo, that's three IBTL's...not bad.

David Killens's picture
@ fatalriots2020

@ fatalriots2020

Are you Dennis Markuze? The well-known nutcase from Montreal?

p.s. I like Turtles.

dogalmighty's picture
@PoopyGnome

@PoopyGnome

"p.s. I like Turtles."

LOL.

Most excellent.

PS. IBTL

boomer47's picture
@David

@David

"Are you Dennis Markuze? The well-known nutcase from Montreal?"

I think the link might be clue.

At least some things haven't changed. Still the same sad little puppy as ever.

Dennis, do start taking your meds again,there's a good chap.

Whitefire13's picture
Oh god David !!!!! LOL!!!

Oh god David !!!!! LOL!!! Jesus fuck, you got me laughing !!!! Second time you’ve called out a Canadian easterner (shouldn’t never called me a redneck when I first showed up - karma’s gettin’ you)... ;)

dogalmighty's picture
@DM

@DM

If you would, please answer the following three mathematics questions;

(-12) * (1+2+3+.....infinity) =

eiπ + 6 =

1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1=

Now cross reference those numbers to the forum rules numbers...and...Viola. Just say'in.

In before the lock.

Whitefire13's picture
@doG ...shit ...now I’m off

@doG ...shit ...now I’m off doing math ...

dogalmighty's picture
@puganada 1, 5, 12 :)

@puganada

1, 5, 12

:)

Nyarlathotep's picture
[splithairs]The first

[splithairs]The first problem contains an abuse of notation, and the 2nd has a typo :P[/splithairs]

Sheldon's picture
On the topic of the recent

On the topic of the recent protests, this struck me as very profound.

You keep saying it's horrible that an innocent black man was killed, but destroying property has to stop.

When you should be saying it's horrible that property is being destroyed, but killing innocent black men has to stop..

Some people seem to be prioritising the wrong part, Trump certainly seems to give that impression.

Sadly a worthwhile topic has been avoided, because the thread author is an insane troll.

Whitefire13's picture
Sheldon! Exactly! Like Trump

Sheldon! Exactly! Like Trump encouraging gun toting religitards taking over govt building (as peaceful protest) -no army - no national guard - no bunker baby - or wall around whitehouse ...

But “mad” at a system that prioritizes a military police force, ignores “bad apples” within their ranks (and covers the bad apple’s asses until “caught) ....ooohhhh - then it’s considered “insurgency” (that’s how the military can be legally placed on the us soil), terrorism, rioting, political conspiracy, etc etc AND he can call out “unidentifiable ‘enforcers’” to help protect himself. What the fuck is he afraid of!!?!????

Pic of Trudeau (same issue)...

Trump is soooo lacking in empathy. Sooooo unable to admit mistakes. Sooooo arrogant and stupid.

And as an outsider, and neighbor - I have no fuckin clue whether the USA will get its shit together - I feel like I’m living beside the abused woman with unruly kids that keeps recycling the same “type” of man through her house. Except this last guy is waving a gun around with his “anger issues”.

EDITED to add: American neighbor - I am in no way saying to “revamp” a political system (open the door to out and out facism) BUT there has to be SOME laws not being enforced within the system AND some means of political balance and communication.

Attachments

Attach Image/Video?: 

Yes
dogalmighty's picture
What the hell is the northern

What the hell is the northern dummy doing now?

Oh...don't tell me...the same as the talking yam.

Attachments

Attach Image/Video?: 

Yes
Whitefire13's picture
Lol doG! Our northern dummy

Lol doG! Our northern dummy is kneeling for 8-9 min with protesters. No tear gas required.

One thing Trudeau is, which Trump lacks, is empathic (in the ability to empathize - not the woo-woo use) and a tendency towards idealism. I always saw it as a but of weakness and nativity, however it does encompass a Canadian strength we do tend to share (despite ourselves). Why do you think we’re known for our “sorry’s, eh?!?!”

dogalmighty's picture
@igloopug

@igloopug

Ummmmm, check your mouth for a hook, line and sinker...politics = continuous photo ops.

Literally, the only time I have seen honesty from him in public ever, were his tears at a Hip concert, (in Gord we trust), even then he used his clout as head dummy, to get in free to see one of their last concerts. At least he has a better head of hair than basement baby. The camera sure loves him.

Whitefire13's picture
Lol!!! Yes, politicians

Lol!!! Yes, politicians photo op:)

Yup. Lots and lots - sorry, no hooks in mouth.

Sheldon's picture
Some ugly clashes with police

Some ugly clashes with police in London. A small core of protestors attacked police, threw missiles including bicycles at mounted police causing one police horse to bolt, the policewoman thrown from the horse sustained quite severe injuries.

There are also fears that these mass protests will cause spikes in spread of Covid 19.

While the anger at racism is justified, and peaceful protest a cornerstone of democracy, I do wonder if this kind of mass gathering is the best way to protest in the current pandemic.

I'm torn between the legal right and moral duty to protest, and the inevitable danger to public safety. There are always those just looking for clashes with the police, who sadly recognised any large gathering as an opportunity. I hope the police officer makes a speedy recovery from her injuries, and that the guilty are swiftly caught and justice served.

Hopefully all of this global action will at least have a positive effect on tackling racism.

Whitefire13's picture
The COVID is one of the first

The COVID is one of the first thing I thought of. Stats should tell us more in the next 2-3 weeks.

I do not agree with the looting or violence- I agree some look for opportunities to engage in criminal activity...and “get away” with it. (Hmmmm regardless of color, “people” with certain personalities enjoy criminal acts)

dogalmighty's picture
In the last week, I have

In the last week, I have heard,

"looting is owed to us, from our poor treatment in the past."

...so, becoming a criminal and looting is as acceptable as peaceful demonstration?

Or shooting and killing a well respected person as he was securing a jewelry store, is as acceptable as peaceful demonstration?

Whitefire13's picture
Nope.

Nope.

Excuses - that’s all, just in the opposite end of the spectrum.

Whitefire13's picture
Fair representation?

Fair representation?

Religion I’m familiar with WTBTS Governing Body (oversees est 6-7 million worldwide)

Criticized - yes.

Attachments

Attach Image/Video?: 

Yes
Whitefire13's picture
Canadian political cabinet

Canadian political cabinet (oversees 36-37 million)

Criticized - yes.

Attachments

Attach Image/Video?: 

Yes
Whitefire13's picture
@doG and posters/lurkers

@doG and posters/lurkers

I do not mean to hog the thread ;) but I have been assess current events and what meaning they have for me and in turn society in general.

I took a test (by Harvard lol) and discovered I am moderately preferential to the Caucasian race. At first, I thought “whaaaa????”, I’ve dated outside my race and personally assess people on their character and actions. So I thought about it. In my area, from the time I was born, I was only exposed to “Caucasian faces”. TV/media started to change that and then Canadian immigration through the decades as well. My exposure to other races and cultures has evolved and grown through my life. I also chuckled because I had linked at one point (to remember better) in the test the “b” words black/bad whereas I was always thinking w/b or b/g or w/g and then b/b - the mental “sound association” made it easier....so I don’t “know”. And preference isn’t the same as prejudice. I prefer, physically, larger chubbier men to shorter, skinny ones (for whatever reason I find it more attractive) but I’m not prejudiced against small skinny men (make sense?)

I don’t know how society in general will come to terms with the issues the protests worldwide are raising. I don’t know “what filters” each person, tribe, nation, institution is running the current events through - nor do I have “control” over how it will be “decided”. My boys told me outright that they are prepared for the “white guilt” that they are now receiving online and I was once told to “shut up” because of “white-privilege” ...

I just hope that as a whole we continue on the path of exposing, discussing, acceptance ... after all, that’s how women “were given” their recognition and “segregation” was ended and “religious” abuses have been addressed and investigated...

Pages

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.