A god on trial

14 posts / 0 new
Last post
Ellie Harris's picture
A god on trial

Since so much focus lately seems to have been on the god of the biblical text, let us start with that god. For the purposes of this topic we shall start from the position that a god exist and it is the one from the bible. Give your reasons on why this god should not be praised and ignored or why this god should be praised and followed.

Subscription Note: 

Choosing to subscribe to this topic will automatically register you for email notifications for comments and updates on this thread.

Email notifications will be sent out daily by default unless specified otherwise on your account which you can edit by going to your userpage here and clicking on the subscriptions tab.

CyberLN's picture
I will borrow from an unknown

I will borrow from an unknown writer: the difference between me and that god is that if I saw a child being raped, I would do everything in my power to stop it.

Spewer's picture
Along that same line:

Along that same line:

"If I had the power that the New Testament narratives say that Jesus had, I would not cure one person of blindness, I would make blindness impossible; I would not cure one person of leprosy, I would abolish leprosy." - Joseph Lewis

CyberLN's picture
Thanks for that Spewer. I

Thanks for that Spewer. I was unfamiliar with Joseph Lewis. Read a bit about him just now and am looking forward to reading more.

secularhumanist's picture
lets be honest the God from

lets be honest the God from the bible or any text seems ignorant and has a big ego and doesnt use logic

Ellie Harris's picture
Yet CyberLN would a proactive

Yet CyberLN would a proactive gawwd make it worthy for you praise and bow to?

CyberLN's picture
Excellent question Ellie! I

Excellent question Ellie! I guess if there were a god who was proactive and I saw actual evidence of that, instead of the lack of evidence, I would become a believer. That's not to say, however, I would like that god. That god would have to step up and be a decent god, not a jerk. But bow down to it? Nope.

Travis Paskiewicz's picture
Are you kidding me? As a

Are you kidding me? As a former christian, simply reading the Bible proves that, aside from being evidenceless, is highly immoral. Ever since mans begining "Morality" has been a developing endeavor to try to bridge the gap between our base human nature to provide for ourselves and our family (tribe if you prefer, i like the term Social Group or even Society) and interact with people from outside other Societies. While in the Bibles day it was a revolutionary text on the conduct of humans, it's very highly outdated. The old testament was especially brash in the treatment of homosexuals, women, and other Societies. I would even go so far as to say it was to the Jews what Mein Kompf was to the Nazis, especially in its views of Jewish as "God's Chosen People" and the blatant disregard for human life the Jewish showed in exterminating the Societies already existing on the land god "Promised" for them. The new testament embraces some new ideas about humbility, loving equally your neighbors, a slight increase in womens roles, but it really only applied to within the christian community, which in turn became gods chosen people....

Parker Mont Blanc's picture
If the god is as loving and

If the god is as loving and as merciful as the born again Christians make him out to be, then he is worthy of praise and devotion. However, born agains are known to disregard the numerous bibilical verses that make out their god as the jealous, irrational, bigoted and merciless.

SammyShazaam's picture
The Judaic god makes it clear

The Judaic god makes it clear in the 10 commandments that he's a jealous god, the only god, and there should be no other god before him. I always wondered, that if he were really the only bearded white guy in the sky, why does he need so much ego stroking, and why is he so threatened by us entertaining the possibility of other gods?

Anyway, the born again christians don't really paint the picture of a loving merciful god, just an egotistical one. He doesn't give a damn what you do or how awful it was or who you did it to, but as long as you love and praise him he'll save you from the torturous eternal pit of hell he's created for people who don't.

No thanks.

Ellie Harris's picture
"If the god is as loving and

"If the god is as loving and as merciful as the born again Christians make him out to be, then he is worthy of praise and devotion."-

Would that love and mercy be negated by the fact that this god rules your entire existence and can & if it deems it necessary punish you for a thought?

Travis Paskiewicz's picture
I think that is what parker

I think that is what parker is iterating, that the god the christians and muslims preach places an emphasis on love. Though in most holy books, god is more intolerant and vindictive than loving and merciful.

Parker Mont Blanc's picture
@ Ellie, as Travis stated,

@ Ellie, as Travis stated, Christians package the Christian god as all loving, ignoring the glaring evidence the Bible presents. This will sound strange coming from an atheist, but reading the Bible does show the truth about the (fictional) Christian god's nature.

Ellie Harris's picture
So I think this trial is

So I think this trial is concluded.

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.