Theist Faith

46 posts / 0 new
Last post
Aposteriori unum's picture
Between all the phone calls,

Between all the phone calls, and putting food that people paid for on tables, and healing the sick that doctors are working on and remembering what he told each Priest and pastor that can hear him so they don't get mixed up, killing babies, creating virtual particles, playing catch with Jesus, helping people on both sides win wars... I mean, who has the time?

Sheldon's picture
posteriori Unum "Between all

posteriori Unum "Between all the phone calls, and putting food that people paid for on tables, and healing the sick that doctors are working on and remembering what he told each Priest and pastor that can hear him so they don't get mixed up, killing babies, creating virtual particles, playing catch with Jesus, helping people on both sides win wars... I mean, who has the time?"

Indeed, and then there is taking the form of a ghost to rape a virgin, so she can give birth to him in human form, that is also his son, and remain a virgin according to some. All so that he can allow himself to be tortured and killed, but not for long, in order to appease himself, when 2 humans he created disobeyed him by eating some fruit they had been denied, but ate it anyway when a nefariously sneaky talking snake he created tempted them in a garden, where despite being omniscient he failed to see the danger of placing all three within easy harms reach of each other.

Maybe it was all those hundreds of millions of years tinkering with dinosaurs that distracted him?

This from Heller's catch 22 springs to my mind, it seems apropos...

"'Don't tell me God works in mysterious ways,' Yossarian continued, hurtling on over her objection. 'There's nothing so mysterious about it. He's not working at all. He's playing. Or else He's forgotten all about us. That's the kind of God you people talk about - a country bumpkin, a clumsy, bungling, brainless, conceited, uncouth hayseed. Good God, how much reverence can you have for a Supreme Being who finds it necessary to include such phenomena as phlegm and tooth decay in His divine system of creation? What in the world was running through that warped, evil, scatological mind of His when He robbed old people of the power to control their bowel movements? Why in the world did He ever create pain?'"

Joseph Heller, Catch-22,

Sheldon's picture
Maybe a deity is testing us

Maybe a deity is testing us in order to weed out the superstitious and gullible ones? Why else would a deity create us with the ability to reason, use science and logic, and then expect us to abandon it all for faith in unevidenced superstition?

I'm dubious of course, but it's a more rational explanation than any religious claims I've encountered.

Sheldon's picture
Breezy "Believing God exists

Breezy "Believing God exists is the most useless bit of knowledge. It doesn't get you into heaven and it doesn't make you holy."

For once we agree.

Woodsmithe77's picture
belief in god is not useless,

belief in god is not useless, merely not transformative.
now we need to talk about free will vs. determinism...

Grinseed's picture
As a student of history I am

As a student of history I am just not interested in ‘what if’ scenarios. The Abrahamic religions simply would not even exist if their god did not insist on faith. Belief is an integral part of any religion. Just thinking a god exists is the basic expression of a faith.
Yes, as an atheist, I agree faith is useless and further, not even a virtue, but for religions it’s an absolute must. The christian bible is full of demands for faith. It is an issue that affects christians at every point of their involvement with the religion: from the new convert deciding to make a commitment to that faith; to the worshipper seeking to express that faith (they even spent centuries preparing set prayers to ask god to deepen that faith, whatever that means) and to the backslider struggling with the final release from it.
My original point was they waste time meddling with fact and evidence and you tube trying to convince anyone that god exists, because they do not even seem to understand the basis of what faith is.
To be forgiven by any god you first have to have faith that god exists.

Woodsmithe77's picture
Grinseed,

Grinseed,
You seem to be saying that the existence of a thing requires belief in a thing. Everything then is subject to ones belief in said thing?
Or does your logic extend only to the metaphysical? I would propose that God cannot exist and not exist at the same time, like anything else.
The question of Gods existence must be answered first, all other discussion is pointless. You notice nobody is defending the existence of the Easter bunny, Santa Clause or even Thor? Those are all proven to be false. the only Deity left standing is God with the big G.
Why is it that all of the other (man made) gods are gone and only one remains?
i propose that science has done it's job and revealed truth from the lies.
If you think that God does not exist, then you have just as much faith as any theist, and if you are merely saying I don't know, then we can discuss it.

Aposteriori unum's picture
Can you worship something

Can you worship something that you don't believe exists? You could worship the idea. Or how about this... Would you wear a raincoat if you believed it would never rain again? You could wear one if you believed it would even if you were wrong. Or you could wear one for another reason altogether, but to protect you from rain that you believe will never come would necessitate a strong cognitive dissonance.

So yes, it matters in that your belief informs your actions.

Sheldon's picture
"The question of Gods

"The question of Gods existence must be answered first, all other discussion is pointless. You notice nobody is defending the existence of the Easter bunny, Santa Clause or even Thor? Those are all proven to be false. the only Deity left standing is God with the big G."
>>A claim is not valid until it is proved false, else all unfalisifiable claims would be valid, that's absurd. I donlt believe in those things you claim are 'proved' not to exist, because like your deity no one has demonstrated proper evidence for them.
-----------------------
"Why is it that all of the other (man made) gods are gone and only one remains?"
>>Which one is that? Vishnu, Ganesha, Brahma, Shiva, Indra, Deva, Trimurti, Garuda, Brhaspati, Krishna, Rama, Agni, Prajapati, Kartikeya, Surya, or Varuna?

Do you know what special pleading means?
----------------------------------------------------------
"i propose that science has done it's job and revealed truth from the lies."
>>Then you don't understand what science is, or what it does.
-------------------------------------------------
"If you think that God does not exist, then you have just as much faith as any theist, and if you are merely saying I don't know, then we can discuss it."
>>Do you usual believe things exist when you don't know whether they are real? What about all the Hindu deities above, do you have separate faiths for each deity you deny exists? I don't believe in things until proper evidence is demonstrated for them, and these attempts to reverse the burden of proof are not compelling arguments at all.

Tin-Man's picture
@Mark and others Re:

@Mark and others Re: Sheldon's comment about other gods

Hey there, Mark. How ya doin'? Looking forward to a happy holiday, I hope.

I've been following this thread and it has been delightful reading some of the arguments. Normally I would not jump into these discussions, but Sheldon's statement about all the other gods caught my attention and brought a question to mind. I have noticed over and over again during many discussions throughout the forum that whenever somebody mentions all the other gods that are still worshipped in this world, no theist ever seems willing to address that issue. As Sheldon (and others) said, there are many, many other gods worshipped by many different people and societies as a whole, and each person/society believes their respective god(s) to be just as real as you believe your god to be. Right? As I believe you have already stated (Please correct me if I am wrong.), you wholeheartedly do not believe in all those other gods, as you believe your God is the only one true god. And, obviously, we as atheists believe in NONE of the gods, including yours. But while you (and others) seem to simply dismiss all the other gods as not being real, for some strange reason atheists are somehow "required" to provide PROOF that YOUR God does not exist. In that respect, why are YOU (and others) not required to provide proof that all those other gods do not exist? And if faith is required to NOT believe in YOUR God, then - by that reasoning - YOU (and others) are required to have just as much faith to not believe in all those other gods. Anyway, just wanted to toss that out there as food for thought.

Grinseed's picture
Mark no, I don't believe a

Mark no, I don't believe a thing exists because someone has faith in it. Nothing in the real world is subject to belief, it either exists or it doesn't.

My logic does not extend to the metaphysical because I don't think the supernatural realm exists.

As an atheist I have no faith in any god.
As an agnostic I am prepared to admit we may never know if a god exists, mainly because I know I really do not know everything.

Science's job is to explain how the physical natural world operates. It deals with incorrect information, not lies, it has no moral aspect. It is a strictly self modifying methodology that strives to attain truth about the physical world. Science's job is far from done, there is so much more to explore and discover.

Why God-with-the-big-G still stands is, as I have explained elsewhere on AR, one of those things that fascinates me and I spend a good deal of time reading about it. It does not mean I believe it, I do believe in the power it has over other people through history and today but I don't subscribe to it.

My op was referencing the obsession theists have for trying to prove God-with-the-big-G exists when there is no need when this god demands faith and not evidence. And despite what else has been written here the bible is full of such demands.

Tin-Man's picture
Hello, all. Don't mean to

Hello, all. Don't mean to interrupt, but I have been following this debate from the beginning, and I felt compelled to take a moment to extend a sincere "Thank you" to all involved (particularly to Apost and John 6IX). Although I am able to understand the concepts and arguments easily enough, the level of the discussion is such that I would have very little of significance to contribute, Nevertheless, I just want to say it has been a pleasure so far watching such a magnificent exchange of intellect. It has been grandly entertaining and most informative, and the mutual respect displayed by the primary participants has been especially commendable. Ladies and gentlemen, in my own humble opinion, this has been a fine example of how serious debates should be properly conducted. Again, I say, "Thank you."

Sky Pilot's picture
Grinseed,

Grinseed,

Why are you willing to believe in some crazy person's delusions about his imaginary deity? If you are willing to believe in some unknown person's delusions why then do you deny the possibility that other people's delusions aren't real?

In the biblical fairy tale crazy people were running around claiming that their delusions were real and that every other crazy person's delusions were false. They even killed the other crazy people because they wouldn't believe in their delusions. It's still happening today around the world.

The reality is that not one deity of any kind has ever done anything that would be classified as godly in scope since the first con man created his deity to control his more superstitious buddies and to enrich himself. Moses was a master of the con job. His supposed miracles were pure BS and didn't convince anyone so he killed a bunch of non-believers in order to get them to toe the line. He was just a thug.

Grinseed's picture
Diotrephes, first off, I do

Diotrephes, first off, I do NOT believe in other people's religions, but are you suggesting I must not study debate or consider them?

I understand that, for you, no religion is worthy of discussion. For you as you've everyone who has belief is a deluded crazy person, and you are willing to discount them and their crazy ideas. That's ok, but I seen no value in just demeaning or insulting from the sidelines. Religious people just get more defensive about their beliefs when attacked or abused, so what the fuck does that achieve? You only strengthen their beliefs, great win for atheism.

Have you ever argued for science with a creationist who didn't understand the scientific method? Damn frustrating.
Have you ever disputed religion with a believer who tossed bible verses at you as if they were proof positive arguments. You can make a lot of progress when you are familiar with those verses and you treat people with respecct. I also read histories about how the bible was written and put together which should be evidence alone that it has been written by men.

Something you don't know about me. My previously agnostic brother freaked out once and took his wife and kids into the folds of a brethren cult, one of those manipulative mind fuck organisations that control tribes of families under quasi Mosaic regulation. I argued with him, his wife and then members of his group til I they realised I was too sane to convert. I still fight that fight to get my brother back. Its damn hard and I am behind fortified enemy lines. You don't know crazy deluded like I do. These cults are the worst expression of religion and epitomise Jesus' demand to hate your family, your real family.

I have lost my brother. And I have learned honey works better than vinegar. You and others misunderstand my interest in the bible and other peoples beliefs. I don't believe any of it but I use it to try to persuade believers by using their bible against them. We all know its badly written and despite all the false editing, there's a lot of contradictions and patently false information in it.

I would rather the world was without religion, but its never going to happen. You ever been to a third world nation where 90+% live around the poverty level? Most of the old Spanish colonies are like that and the poor have been subjected to the Catholic indoctrination and they cling desperately fanatically to the sweet lies because that's all they have and ever will have. Try telling them they are all crazy deluded idiots. Every time I even touched on the bible not being the word of god I was treated as if I was insane.

I lost my brother and I cant save the world, but rather than just yell at clouds and tell religious folks they're crazy I keep them engaged and try to keep them to account. Over time my brother and his mates toss fewer and fewer bible verses at me and then only with extreme caution. And as a booklover and hobby history student I cant avoid the affects of religion on language and world events. Religion is more than churches, books and crazed delusionists its all around you and even in the words you use.

And here's something you might not know Dio, while Moses was indeed a thug, he never existed. He and the whole Exodus saga were made up. Jewish theologists and archaeologists declared it all a fiction after years of exploration and research, that includes all of Joshua too and yet Mosaic law is the basis of Judaism. How is that for crazy?

I expect in decades to come there will be a church for Potterainists, but I am ready for them now. Read.

bigbill's picture
I guess because they have a

I guess because they have a love relationship with there GOD. And they want to encourage more people to follow there God. Its called evangelism Some times unless you put your self into describing your faith the message doesn`t totally get out. That is the ongoing question isn`t it "Why doesn`t this God provide more evidence of his existence and purpose for ones life".

Pages

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.