Subscription Note:
Choosing to subscribe to this topic will automatically register you for email notifications for comments and updates on this thread.
Email notifications will be sent out daily by default unless specified otherwise on your account which you can edit by going to your userpage here and clicking on the subscriptions tab.
The topic makes no sense. Rational free thinking leads to beliefs that are rational. Non, rational thinking leads to beliefs that are non-rational. Is there something else you need to know? Everything you hold to be true is a belief. It is a belief, whether or not it is rational.
@DJA
Might be interested in replying to a claim or argument .
What is your position on the topic and why?
With beliefs, one begins with a presupposition, and works towards rationalizing it. In free thinking, one follows the evidence and logic to arrive at a conclusion, regardless of the expected outcome.
DJA: Rational free thinking versus beliefs
Did you forget to include your argument?
Your title is synonymous with "commitment to truth versus make-believe".
My response to OP...
Mike Tyson vs. Pee Wee Herman.
John F Kennedy VS Donald LeTrump
William T.G. Morton vs Mary Teresa
Madame Curie vs Eva Braun
Bullwinkle and Rocky vs. Batman and Robin
Robocop vs. Terminator
Three Dog Night vs. 3 Doors Down
Orca vs. Flipper
Edit to add:
Little Rascals vs. Keystone Cops
As Cognostic says a belief can be rational or irrational, it's the affirmation of a claim, how you arrived at that conclusion determines the validity of a belief.
The more objective evidence one has the more credence one can assign the belief. Contrary evidence, no evidence or irrational claims made to support the belief should mean we attach less credence to it. If of course we care whether what we believe is true or not.
For a rational thinker, belief is tentative knowledge that is subject to revision as more facts are learned.
Belief in a religious context is specifically the act of holding contradictory ideas in one's mind simultaneously without being aware of the contradiction. Educated believers are aware of the real world and how it works, but they also hold the idea that it is magically controlled and manipulated by an invisible sky-spook. They know that consciousness depends on a functioning brain supported by a living body, but they also believe that they will somehow survive death.
George Orwell coined the name "doublethink" for this phenomenon in "1984".
@OP
What is your belief?
This reminds me of the Mike Myers "Coffee Talk" skit on SNL:
"Rational free thinking versus belief. Talk among yourselves!"
Why are so many profile names getting changed all of a sudden???
Everyone has beliefs.
The 'rational free thinker' and the irrational theist have beliefs.
A belief is simply, the psychological state in which one is convinced a claim, premise or proposition is true, or likely true.
In other words, if one is convinced a claim, premise or proposition is true, they have a belief.
The reasons one is convinced, is where the rational thinking part comes in.
Rational reasons for having a belief: demonstrable and falsifiable evidence, reasoned argument, and valid and sound logic.
Irrational reasons for having a belief: 'feelings'. ancient texts, fallacious arguments, raised with a specific belief, etc.
For some reason, it seems that the word "belief" became a dirty word among some atheists. As if, a belief is always irrational, or without evidential warrant. When in truth, there are good reasons to hold a belief, and bad reasons.
"For some reason, it seems that the word "belief" became a dirty word among some atheists."
Because when in conversation with some theists, that word is a trap. They confuse it with "faith".
Obviously a theist troll out for his first drive by post.
Careful out there, those theists are aggressive drivers!!!!
Attachments
Attach Image/Video?: