Is theism comforting?

41 posts / 0 new
Last post
Kataclismic's picture
It's more like a two-year-old

It's more like a two-year-old that doesn't understand reality. You can tell them about reality and ask them to grow up but... they're two.

SomeBODIEShero's picture
@kata

@kata

Sometimes the most innocent and least educated of us have the deepest insight...

Kataclismic's picture
Insight? No, insight belongs

Insight? No, insight belongs to Antony van Leeuwenhoek, who discovered protozoa instead of believing in witches.

SomeBODIEShero's picture
@kata

@kata

I live with a woman of the the age of 94. A lot of what she says about her past I either shrug off or roll my eyes at.

I often wonder though, here is a woman with 3X my years on this planet. Why is it so easy for me to discard what she says as truth? Why do I feel like, with a fraction of her experiences, that mine equal truth, and hers equal crazy? I think about this a lot. Because although I recognize it is hard to discern fact from fiction, I also realize my own bias clouds my judgement of truth. Maybe she is right? What do I know about life in the 1940s? Who am I to tell her what she experienced was wrong?

My point is, everyone has insight unique to yours. It is the gravest of “sins” to think that you understand everything. And even worse to discredit the understanding of others that have lived a totally different life than you...

Kataclismic's picture
What does the fact that you

What does the fact that you shrug off what a 94-year-old woman says about the life she lead with no reason at all have to do with insight, again? You feel you are more insightful because you think you know better or do you think that she is more insightful and you fail to see it?

Fact is what is discovered, fiction is based on bias.

Sheldon's picture
SomeBODIEShero" I recognize

SomeBODIEShero" I recognize it is hard to discern fact from fiction"

No it isn't, objective evidence is what separates fact from fiction. That is why methods like science, that best use this are demonstrably more successful at explaining reality.

Sheldon's picture
SomeBODIEShero "Sometimes

SomeBODIEShero "Sometimes the most innocent and least educated of us have the deepest insight..."

Yet another tedious unevidenced claim, can you demonstrate any objective evidence this latest piece of rhetoric has any validity?

Account Inactive's picture
@ LogicFTW

@ LogicFTW

I couldn't agree more. Christianity is based on reward or punishment, there is no getting away from that. Saying that comfort is just a biproduct of their religion is dishonest in my opinion. As you have pointed out, without the carrot or the stick there would be absolutely no sense in their faith, I say faith because that is all they have.

Yes it gives people comfort, but why should their comfort come at a price to others? Do they not see how selfish they're being? I will never understand how an empty promise can warp peoples judgement in this way. We all know the damage that is caused by this nonsense, it's about time that we started to take child protection seriously. Religions get a free pass to emotionally abuse children, an endless conveyor belt of young minds to tarnish..Why? Why do they get away with it?

Are we ever going to grow up and face facts, or are we doomed to let fear continue to rule our lives.

LogicFTW's picture
@Workingclasshero

@Workingclasshero

Christianity is based on reward or punishment, there is no getting away from that.

I seen quite a few debates with theist here done by me and others where the debate sort of devolves to, making the god concept extremely vague and highly metaphysical so that the god idea is out of reach of any sort of fact checking or testing, evidence etc. But then they jump from a god they defined as essentially inconsequential (no need to worship or even really think about such a god concept it is so vague and "unreachable.") And then take it all the way back to why there specific god described in their prefered religious text and church why you should say for instance "accept jesus in your heart." There is no middle ground, they essentially define their god out of existence then expect you to have a very "personal and accepting" relationship with their god (or jesus in some cases.) All without showing the middle ground, the how to get there.

So I will argue that heaven/hell etc makes no sense, has huge reasoning holes and logical flaws in the concept, they will run down the path of a "god" that is outside of time and the universe, but then soon as they are done with that run all the way back to "have faith and accept jesus in your heart, etc." They are essentially talking about two different gods and using the "untouchable" status of the vague god essentially defined out of existence by them, to safeguard their god from argument, but then soon as that is over go right back to making god a huge part of their lives that they have a personal conversation with, why they need to "spread their religion on others" etc. It is usually pretty obvious to us, but the people that make the arguments are usually oblivious to it.

Are we ever going to grow up and face facts, or are we doomed to let fear continue to rule our lives.

Some of us already have (at least in regards to religion. Some of us will (hopefully more and more.) But I think there is a lot of people that will continue to let fear rule their lives, some really have almost no choice in it. A person with little financial means, in the middle of a highly religious area, especially islam, where everyone they know is highly religious, I would actually recommend they stay closeted about the fact they are not theist. (Just like I would recommend to someone that was say christian in that area/situation.)
 
 

▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬

I am an atheist that always likes a good debate
Please include @LogicFTW for responses to me
Tips on forum use. ▮ A.R. Member since 2016.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬

Cognostic's picture
Hell.... A warm, sun

Hell.... A warm, sun ripened, tomato, picked right off the vine, is comforting when you sit on it in just the right way. But too much of any good thing makes you look like an idiot!!! (Just for fun)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A67jp7TqNAg

Pages

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.